Homosexuality & American Psychiatry by Ronald Bayer Essay

Homo versedity & American Psychiatry by Ronald Bayer - Essay ExampleTraditional determine Coalition (TVC) claims that the removal of crotchet from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) list is a political decision without any scientific foundation, no more than than a victory of harmful homosexual urban legends that have infiltrated every aspect of our culture (TVC). The declaration does not oppose Bayers claims promptly rather, the author uses Bayers book as evidence. However, it does oppose Bayers stance on the transposes in APA in 1972, cutting simply the close dramatic passage out of the context. From the perspective of logic, this is an example of ambiguity created by quoting out of context (Gula 97). The declaration of TVC cites the passage in which Bayer really describes the look of homosexual activists as violent they attacked APA in 1970 and greeted the speaker on the Associations conference with exclamation about Auschwitz and the swearword s like motherfucker (Bayer 103). TVCs condition covers neither the pretext of such violent actions nor the aggressive behavior of some APA members described by Bayer. Furthermore, the article and the book argon parts of the discourses that oppose separately other, one claiming that homosexuality is a disease (TVC) and the other implying that this is a variation of normal sexual habit (Bayer). In the TVC article, the following claims about the issue are made1)Homosexuality was removed from the DSM list under the political pressure and without any significant scientific support. An instructive example is how both sides of the debate presuppose about the lack of firsthand expert evidence from the APA members. To Bayer, Kent Robinson (who had never been an expert in homosexuality) is a disinterested scientist helping the fighters for human rights Since Robinson knew no homosexual psychiatrists, he somewhat reluctantly agreed to chair the gay panel (104). However, to Socarides, one of the most active supporters of the TVC line, Spitzers lack of background in the studies of homosexuality is only the sign of professional incompetence of the APA member Spitzer, who to my knowledge had never previously published a single article on homosexuality or the sexual deviations, had composed a position paper on the meaning and content of homosexuality (Socarides). 2) The imbalance of power was on the side of homosexual activists (who threatened APA) - whence the Trojan Horse metaphor For the next 18 years, the APA decision served as a Trojan horse, opening the gates to widespread psychological and social change in sexual customs and mores (TVC). It follows that the change was not relevant to the needs of the society but was only the manipulation of a small group. 3) Diagnosing homosexuality as a mental disorder helps homosexuals. The Accuracy of the Review The accuracy of any review quoting only small part of the source is doubtful at best. The TVCs review is accurate in c iting facts still, it is entirely misleading about the assessment of those facts. It